Skip to content

Knowledge Base

Manual vs auto-generated FAQs in Shopify Knowledge Base

Published

The three FAQ creation paths in Knowledge Base

Shopify's Knowledge Base app exposes three FAQ creation paths. Auto-generated FAQs are pulled from four settings surfaces (Language, Customer accounts, Shipping and delivery, Return rules). Manually created FAQs are authored by the merchant directly. From-unanswered FAQs are converted from the Top unanswered questions surface — observed buyer questions that don't have an answer yet. Auto-FAQs can be overridden but not deleted; manual FAQs are fully editable; unanswered-converted FAQs become manual once answered.

All three paths are documented on the FAQ-management page1. The verbatim guidance on answer length applies to all three: 'a brief 1-2 sentence answer.'

How the override behavior works

Auto-generated FAQs cannot be deleted — they regenerate from the underlying settings. The merchant can Override an auto-FAQ to replace its answer with custom text, or use 'Return to default' to revert. The override is sticky until reverted. Manually-created FAQs are fully editable and deletable.

Practical implication: if the auto-generated answer is wrong, fix the underlying setting first (return rule, shipping zone, etc.) rather than overriding. The override preserves a divergence between the FAQ answer and the actual store setting, which causes accuracy drift over time. Override only when the underlying setting is correct but the auto-generated wording is awkward.

When to use which path

Use auto-generated for settings-derived facts. Use manual for product-category or merchant-knowledge questions Shopify can't pull from settings. Use from-unanswered to convert observed buyer questions into FAQs — this is the highest-signal path because it reflects actual buyer intent, not anticipated questions.

  • Auto-generated: returns policy, shipping zones, delivery times, account behavior. Keep auto, fix underlying setting if wrong.
  • Manual: 'Is this product hypoallergenic?', 'Do you offer wholesale?', 'Where are your products made?' — questions Shopify settings can't answer.
  • From unanswered: weekly review of the Top unanswered questions surface; convert the recurring ones into manual FAQs.

Decision matrix

Five common question types and the path that handles each best. Most stores end up with 15-25 auto-generated FAQs (left alone), 10-20 manual FAQs (covering the product / brand questions), and 5-10 from-unanswered-converted FAQs added weekly as buyer questions reveal them.

Question typeBest pathWhy
Returns policyAuto-generatedPulled from Return rules; fix rule if answer is wrong
Shipping zones / ratesAuto-generatedPulled from Shipping settings
Product-specific question (sizing, materials)ManualSettings can't answer; merchant authors directly
Brand / business question (factory location, wholesale)ManualNot in settings; manual is the only path
Recurring buyer question Shopify didn't anticipateFrom unansweredTop unanswered surface flags it

Keep reading